A version of this article appeared in the daily Threat Status newsletter from The Washington Times. Click here to receive Threat Status delivered directly to your inbox each weekday.
A Kamala Harris administration would continue America’s policy of managing strategic competition with China to avoid war, according to a key plank of the Democrats’ 2024 policy platform made public this week.
The party platform calls for avoiding a costly “spiral to conflict” with China while seeking cooperation, though Beijing has largely rejected such cooperation as part of President Xi Jinping’s push to advance the communist system globally.
Tensions remain high between China and the U.S. in the Indo-Pacific over disputed islands in the South China Sea and over Taiwan, the self-ruled island democracy and major target for annexation by Beijing.
The foreign policy plank of the Democratic platform was completed on July 16, before President Biden withdrew from the presidential race and was replaced by Ms. Harris on the Democratic ticket.
The Democratic National Committee, however, said in releasing the platform that the document strongly reflects the joint work of the president and vice president and offers “a progressive agenda” for the next administration.
The 92-page document hails Mr. Biden’s policies and successes while criticizing former President Donald Trump as a leader who would “dismantle our democracy.”
The platform states that Mr. Biden “has led with conviction” in seeking to secure the U.S. border and reform the nation’s immigration system, though Republicans still see the border crisis as a significant political liability for Democrats and Ms. Harris, specifically.
More broadly, Democrats view the current period of global change as an “inflection point” in an ideological battle between dictatorships and democracies. The party platform says that “democracy — rule by the people — is essential to moving our world forward and uplifting people everywhere.”
The platform says Democrats’ foreign policy will begin with diplomacy and use military force as a tool of last resort. Democrats said they would work with allies to confront major international issues, such as climate change.
The China challenge
On China, the Democrats’ platform touts robust freedom of navigation operations by U.S. Navy warships in the region and support for the Philippines in its growing disputes with China over the disputed Second Thomas Shoal in the Spratly Islands.
Other regional successes touted by Democrats include expanding the U.S. military presence in Japan and adding U.S. military sites in the Philippines — two key Asian allies.
The platform casts all of that against the backdrop of an increasingly powerful China, which represents the kinds of global challenges that the U.S. has not seen in decades.
China “is the only global actor that combines the intention to fundamentally reshape the U.S.-led international order with an increasing military, economic, diplomatic, and technological capacity to do so,” the platform says.
To deal with the challenge, the Democrats’ China policy seeks to avoid conflict through “tough but smart” policies. Those policies oppose Beijing’s unfair trade practices and aim to prevent China from using U.S. openness to obtain technologies that can threaten U.S. and allied security.
Instead of decoupling the closely linked American and Chinese economies, Democrats say they will continue to “de-risk” and diversify economic ties. That means continuing restrictions on exporting sensitive technology, a policy Beijing opposes.
Despite criticizing the past Trump administration policy on tariffs, the Democrats’ platform states that Mr. Biden increased tariffs on Chinese products, including steel, aluminum, semiconductors, electric vehicles, batteries, critical minerals, solar cells, ship-to-shore cranes and medical products.
The platform praises the administration for pushing China to take action to curb the flow of deadly fentanyl into the Americas and for pressing China on climate change. China remains the world’s largest source of greenhouse gas emissions and is continuing to build large numbers of coal-fired power plants.
On Taiwan, the Democrats’ platform vows to “remain steadfast” in working for peace and stability across the 100-mile-wide Taiwan Strait, a flash point where China has stepped up daily saber-rattling sorties by its warplanes and warships.
The platform commits the next Democratic administration to continued adherence to the U.S. one-China policy, which does not recognize mainland sovereignty over Taiwan, other diplomatic communiques and the Taiwan Relations Act, which calls for selling defensive arms to Taiwan.
On the aging U.S. nuclear arsenal, the next administration will continue the costly modernization but keep nuclear forces limited in scope and continue to pursue arms control talks with adversaries, the platform states.
“Aware of exacerbated nuclear proliferation challenges that the world is facing as Russia, the [People’s Republic of China] and North Korea expand and diversify their nuclear arsenals, and in the context of Iran continuing to enrich uranium at dangerous levels, the administration is showing what it means to act responsibly as a nuclear power,” the platform says.
Unlike Beijing and Moscow, where strategic doctrines and actions suggest preparations for the use of nuclear arms in conflicts, Democrats say they will continue a doctrine that limits the use of nuclear arms to strictly deter enemy nuclear strikes.
“Nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought,” the platform says. “The United States is developing and fielding only what is required to deter while signaling openness to future arms control negotiations if competitors are interested.”
The arms talks were emphasized despite a sharp decline in world discussions on limiting nuclear weapons, including between the U.S. and its top global adversaries, Russia and China.
Overall, according to the platform, the next administration will seek to maintain American military advantages through targeted strategic investments in advanced military technology and a modernized nuclear force.
On North Korea, the platform calls for continuing efforts to counter the destabilizing growth of nuclear and missile forces. Pressure on Pyongyang will come from a bolstered trilateral relationship involving Washington, Seoul and Tokyo.
The platform states that cyberwarfare will also be addressed in a Harris administration through improved intelligence and the pursuit of “rules for the road” for artificial intelligence.
Divisions among Democrats
The Middle East plank of the platform states that Mr. Biden and Ms. Harris support a strong, secure and democratic Israel as a vital U.S. interest — though that position could further inflame tensions among factions of the Democratic Party. Many on the far left are increasingly turning against Israel and protesting the Biden administration’s continued support for the Jewish state in its war against Hamas in the Gaza Strip.
Such divisions have been on full display this week as thousands of protesters in Chicago demonstrate against American support for Israel’s military campaign in the Palestinian enclave.
On the other major global conflict raging, the Russia-Ukraine war, Democrats say their central focus will be preventing a wider war in Europe while helping Ukraine defend its sovereignty.
Russia remains a significant threat beyond the Ukraine war and is enlisting North Korea, Iran and China in its efforts to “attack freedom across the world,” the platform says.
The platform states that the administration is building coalitions in the Western Hemisphere to “make America safer and more prosperous.”
For Africa, the Democrats’ policy calls for advancing democracy, economic growth and improving health, as well as addressing climate change.
Democrats may struggle to pitch a clear, convincing foreign policy vision to Americans. The Biden administration has been intensely criticized for its actions over the past three years.
The Wall Street Journal, in an editorial Monday coinciding with the start of the Democratic National Convention, criticized Mr. Biden as “a president most Americans regard as a failure.”
The conservative editorial page said Mr. Biden’s foreign policy legacy will be linked to the outcomes of the wars in Ukraine and the Middle East. The editorial suggested those conflicts were partly the fault of Mr. Biden’s “ignominious withdrawal from Afghanistan,” which was seen as a weakness and emboldened adversaries.
The president “wasn’t able to deter Vladimir Putin from invading Ukraine, nor Iran and its proxies from threatening the very existence of Israel,” the editorial said.
“But history’s harshest verdict may be that, with adversaries on the march, Mr. Biden proposed cuts in U.S. defense spending after inflation every year of his presidency,” the newspaper said. “This will haunt the next president, whoever it is, if the new axis of adversaries in China, Russia, Iran and elsewhere seek to exploit a U.S. military without the means to meet its global commitments.”
• Bill Gertz can be reached at bgertz@washingtontimes.com.
Please read our comment policy before commenting.