OPINION:
Since American troops left Kabul in the summer of 2021, the United States has welcomed more than 79,000 Afghan evacuees.
That’s a testament to U.S. compassion, but a challenge to national security. According to a recent report from the Office of Inspector General, the Department of Homeland Security failed to meet crucial vetting requirements before admitting thousands of Afghans, including at least two who posed a danger to “national security and the safety of local communities.”
Of course, the United States has a vested interest in helping its allies. But that’s no excuse for ignoring protocol. Poorly vetted newcomers could pose a national security risk, and DHS needs to take that possibility seriously.
In August 2021, many Afghans pressed across the tarmac and onto American planes without much vetting. So the United States shipped thousands of evacuees to “lily pad” sites in countries such as Germany, Italy, Kuwait and Qatar, where American officials would clear the migrants for U.S. entry.
At the time, President Biden promised that no refugee would touch U.S. soil without first undergoing “thorough scrutiny.” But in reality, federal officials were consistently sloppy. Nearly 1,300 Afghan evacuees were cleared to fly to America without first providing their fingerprints — and 35 were pushed onto a U.S. airplane without the necessary “green status.”
The confusion continued on U.S. shores, where the government relied on Operation Allies Welcome to resettle newcomers. Unfortunately, officials left a jumbled paper trail, according to the Inspector General’s report. In fact, hundreds of evacuees were admitted without providing satisfactory first or last names, dates of birth, or travel document numbers.
Of the Afghans cleared for U.S. entry, 417 couldn’t provide a first name, 242 had unknown surnames, and more than 11,000 listed Jan. 1 as their date of birth. Nearly 8,000 Afghans brought faulty identification numbers or none at all.
Of course, sloppy paperwork doesn’t imply that each refugee is lying. Many Afghans go by a single name and don’t know their own date of birth.
What fails to reassure, however, is that American officials accidentally admitted or paroled dozens of newcomers with “derogatory information” on file, according to internal DHS records.
One evacuee had just escaped an Afghan prison with the help of the Taliban. The person was eventually deported after a weekslong stay in the United States. The OIG suspects at least 50 Afghan arrivals of posing “potentially significant security concerns,” according to a report from last February.
Some Afghans have already been charged with serious crimes. In October 2021, a refugee allegedly raped an 18-year-old girl in a Montana hotel room. Another Afghan faces charges in the slayings of three men in New Mexico, according to reports. Another allegedly abused a 3-year-old Afghan girl while both were waiting to enter the United States.
It’s time for the government to step in, check its work and remedy its mistakes. So far, however, DHS has rejected the recommendations the OIG report provided. Meanwhile, some in the Senate have pushed to expand Afghans’ eligibility for special immigrant visas.
That’s grossly premature. Mr. Biden should encourage DHS to complete all vetting procedures for admitted or paroled Afghans and to develop a comprehensive plan for future emergencies — as the Inspector General suggested.
That’s a practical way forward. Compassion must not come at the expense of American security.
• James Bowen is a high-energy nuclear physicist from Kansas City, Kansas. He is an avid outdoorsman who is concerned about the upward trajectory of U.S. population, driven by immigration, and its consequences — such as increased urban sprawl, traffic congestion and destruction of wildlife habitat.
Please read our comment policy before commenting.