OAKMONT, Pa. — All the chaos and confusion couldn’t stop Dustin Johnson from proving he had the head to win the U.S. Open.
One year after the most devastating of all his close calls in the major, Johnson won the event by three strokes over Shane Lowry, Scott Piercy and Jim Furyk, closing with a final-round 69 to finish at 4-under-par and capture his first major championship at Oakmont.
Johnson endured two hours of not knowing the size of his lead while the USGA questioned whether he should be penalized one stroke for his ball moving on the fifth green.
Johnson said the ball didn’t move, and the USGA said it would wait until after the final round to decide — and then said it did.
He then took matters into his own hands on Sunday with a 10-foot par save on the 16th hole, a tee shot he smashed down the middle of the 18th fairway and an approach to within five feet for birdie that left no doubt who won on the course widely considered to be the toughest in the country.
Only after he was guaranteed that silver trophy did the USGA assess him a one-shot penalty.
The lingering question was whether this U.S. Open was tougher than it needed to be.
Johnson had a short par putt on the fifth hole and took a few practice strokes, and as he placed the putter behind the ball, it moved slightly — backward. Johnson stepped back and called over the rules official, told him it didn’t move and he tapped in for par.
The USGA later decided to review it, and the timing was peculiar.
Johnson was in deep rough left of the 10th fairway when he was given relief from a television tower in his line-of-sight to the flag. He was able to move left toward the 11th fairway and drop it in the first cut of rough, and he powered it over the tower and onto the green, setting up a par. It was a huge break — within the rules — the kind that major champions often get.
One hole later, the USGA informed they had questions about the ball moving on No. 5.
“After looking at video, the actions he took could have caused the ball to move,” said Jeff Hall, director of rules and open championships for the USGA. “We asked if there was some other reason the ball could have moved. He didn’t state a reason.”
The USGA wanted him to know that a one-shot penalty was likely so he could play accordingly, but it led to confusion over the back nine — for Johnson and for the players trying to catch him.
Shane Lowry, who began the final round with a four-shot lead that he lost on the front nine, caught him when Johnson made his only bogey on the back nine. Were they tied? Was Johnson one shot behind? No one knew.
Johnson played through it all, thinking only of that silver trophy that got away from him at Chambers Bay last year when he had a 12-foot eagle putt to win and then three-putted for par to lose by one to Jordan Spieth.
Lowry, the first player since Payne Stewart at The Olympic Club in 1998 to lose a four-shot lead in the final round of the U.S. Open, lost his putting touch that had carried him to the lowest 54-hole total at Oakmont. He three-putted from long range on three consecutive holes, and Johnson was flawless at the end.
He gave three quick fist-pumps when the birdie putt fell on the 18th, hugged his brother, Austin, who caddies for him and scooped up his son, Tatum, on Father’s Day.
Among the first to greet him was Jack Nicklaus, who won his first major at Oakmont in 1962. The gold medal for the winner is named after Nicklaus.
Please read our comment policy before commenting.