WASHINGTON — An American jailed in Pakistan for the fatal shooting of two armed men was working secretly for the CIA and scouting a neighborhood when he was arrested, a disclosure likely to further frustrate U.S. government efforts to free the man and strain relations between two countries partnered in a fragile alliance in the war on terror.
Raymond Allen Davis, 36, was working as a CIA security contractor for the U.S. Consulate in Lahore, according to former and current U.S. officials, who spoke on condition of anonymity because they weren’t authorized to talk publicly about the incident.
Mr. Davis, a former Special Forces soldier who left the military in 2003, shot the men in what he described as an attempted armed robbery in the eastern city of Lahore as they approached him on a motorcycle. A third Pakistani, a bystander, died when a car rushing to help Mr. Davis struck him. Mr. Davis reportedly was carrying a Glock handgun, a pocket telescope and papers with different identifications.
Meanwhile, the Obama administration insisted anew Monday that Mr. Davis had diplomatic immunity and must be set free.
In a hastily arranged conference call with reporters shortly after details of Mr. Davis’ employment were reported, senior State Department officials repeated the administration’s stance that he is an accredited member of the technical and administrative staff of the U.S. Embassy in Islamabad. They said the Pakistani government had been informed of his status in January 2010 and that Pakistan is violating its international obligations by continuing to hold him.
The officials would not comment on Mr. Davis’ employment but said it was irrelevant to the case because Pakistan had not rejected his status. The officials spoke only on grounds of anonymity because of the sensitivity of the situation.
The revelation that Mr. Davis was an employee of the CIA comes amid a tumultuous dispute over whether he is immune from criminal prosecution under international rules enacted to protect diplomats overseas. New protests in Pakistan erupted after the Guardian newspaper in London decided to publish details about Mr. Davis’ relationship with the CIA.
The United States repeatedly has asserted that Mr. Davis had diplomatic immunity and should have been released immediately. The State Department claims Mr. Davis was “entitled to full criminal immunity in accordance with the Vienna Convention” and was a member of the “technical and administrative staff” at the U.S. Embassy in Islamabad.
The Associated Press learned of Mr. Davis’ working for the CIA last month, immediately after the shootings, but withheld publication of the information because it could endanger his life while he was jailed overseas, with at least some protesters there calling for his execution as a spy.
The AP had intended to report Mr. Davis’ CIA employment after he was out of harm’s way, but the story was broken Sunday by the Guardian. The CIA asked the AP and several other U.S. media outlets to hold their stories as the United States tried to improve Mr. Davis’ security situation.
A U.S. official said Mr. Davis is being held at a jail on the outskirts of Lahore, where there are serious doubts about whether the Pakistanis truly can protect him. The official said the Pakistanis have expressed similar concerns to the United States.
A senior Pakistani intelligence official said the government had taken measures to ensure Mr. Davis’ safety by stepping up security at the facility, removing certain inmates from the prison and sending a contingent of well-trained paramilitaries known as the Rangers.
The State Department said the Pakistani government was informed that Mr. Davis was a diplomat and entitled to immunity when he was assigned to the U.S. Embassy in Islamabad. “We notified the Pakistani government when he arrived in Islamabad,” department spokesman P.J. Crowley said.
Mr. Davis identified himself as a diplomat to police when he was arrested and “has repeatedly requested immunity” to no avail, Mr. Crowley said. The U.S. Embassy said he has a diplomatic passport and a visa valid through June 2012. It also said in a recent statement the United States had notified the Pakistani government of Mr. Davis’ assignment more than a year ago. However, the senior Pakistani intelligence official said that Mr. Davis’ visa application contained bogus U.S. contact information.
Since Pakistani authorities took the ex-Special Forces soldier into custody Jan. 27, U.S. officials said, the situation slowly has escalated into a crisis, threatening the CIA’s ability to wage a dangerous war against al Qaeda and militants. Some members of Congress have threatened to cut off the billions in funding to Pakistan if Mr. Davis isn’t released.
Mr. Davis was attached to the CIA’s Global Response Staff, which provides security overseas to agency bases and stations, former and current U.S. officials told the AP. In that role, he was assigned to protect CIA personnel. One of their duties includes protecting case officers when they meet with sources. On the day he was captured, he was familiarizing himself with the area. He was living in a CIA safe house in Lahore.
“Davis is a protective officer, someone who provides security to U.S. officials in Pakistan,” the U.S official said. “Rumors to the contrary are simply wrong.”
In a YouTube video of local police interrogating him, Mr. Davis said he’s a consultant and he’s with the “RAO,” a reference to the American Regional Affairs Office. Mr. Davis also said at one point he was attached to the U.S. Embassy in Islamabad.
Working for the agency’s GRS comes with risks — sometimes fatal ones. The head of security at the CIA’s base in Khost, Afghanistan, was killed with six others in December 2009 after a suicide bomber detonated a powerful explosive under his belt.
The CIA has a major presence in Pakistan, where it runs the drone program in Islamabad and offensive operations against militants, al Qaeda and Pakistan’s spy agency, Inter-Services Intelligence.
Former and current U.S. officials say the Pakistanis might have been stalling Mr. Davis’ release so he could be extensively questioned, hoping he could provide more information about CIA activities in the troubled country or possibly even identify other agency officers.
The senior Pakistani intelligence official told the AP the two men in the response vehicle that went to aid Mr. Davis, killing the bystander, have left the country. The official said the Pakistani government’s decision to let them leave was a concession to the United States.
The U.S.-Pakistani partnership has begun to fray in recent months. In late 2010, a pair of civil lawsuits filed in the United States accused Pakistan’s spy chief of nurturing terrorists involved in the 2008 Mumbai attacks. Shortly after the lawsuits were filed, the name of the CIA’s top spy in Pakistan was disclosed publicly and his life threatened. He eventually was pulled out of the country in December, a month before the scheduled end of his tour.
A former CIA officer said militants also have threatened the children of ISI officers. And the CIA in recent years has become increasingly concerned about the safety of its officers in outlying areas such as Lahore and Peshawar, a former senior U.S. intelligence source said. But the danger was more pronounced in Lahore, where the CIA learned there might be government elements willing to harm agency officers.
Former CIA officials said the agency officers could have been killed in 2009 when terrorists attacked an ISI compound in Lahore. CIA officers regularly met their counterparts at the compound but didn’t have a meeting scheduled the day of the attack.
Further inflaming tensions, the wife of one of the men Mr. Davis shot committed suicide. She had said she feared her husband’s killer would be freed without trial.
Military records show Mr. Davis, a Virginia native, served a decade in the Army, including five years with the 3rd Special Forces Group in Fort Bragg, N.C., home to the Green Berets.
Mr. Davis also worked for security contractor Blackwater Worldwide, now known as Xe Services.
Mr. Davis and his wife run a Las Vegas-registered company called Hyperion Protective Services. The address for its headquarters is a mailbox at a UPS store in a strip mall. The truth about Mr. Davis’ true employer briefly slipped out after a local television reporter in Colorado called his wife.
In a story posted on the website of Denver’s 9News, the wife provided the name and number of a “CIA spokesperson” in Washington, but the story quickly was taken down, edited and then reposted with new language eliminating any reference to the CIA.
The incident in Pakistan also raises serious questions about how an armed CIA employee could become involved in a fatal shooting with street bandits and allow himself to be captured. Former CIA officers say they were taught to make their way back to the safety of the embassy or consulate in potentially dangerous situations, but the circumstances could have made that impossible in Mr. Davis’ case.
Former CIA officials say this is not the first time an agency employee was detained in a foreign country. In the 1980s, a CIA officer with diplomatic immunity was abducted in Ethiopia after he was suspected of spying. The case was resolved quietly, and the officer eventually was released.
Associated Press writers Oskar Garcia in Las Vegas, Anne Gearan and Matt Apuzzo in Washington, and Kathy Gannon in Islamabad, Pakistan, contributed to this report.
Please read our comment policy before commenting.