For the first time, an externally applied gel has proved capable of blocking the AIDS virus: It cut in half a woman’s chances of getting HIV from an infected partner in a study in South Africa. Scientists called it a breakthrough in the long quest for a tool to help women whose partners won’t use condoms.
The results need to be confirmed in another study, and that level of protection may not be enough to win approval of the vaginal gel in countries like the United States, researchers say. But they are optimistic the microbe-killing product can be improved.
“It’s the first time we’ve ever seen any microbicide give a positive result” that scientists agree is true evidence of protection, said Dr. Anthony Fauci, director of the U.S. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases.
The gel, spiked with the AIDS drug tenofovir, cut the risk of HIV infection by 50 percent after one year of use and 39 percent after 2 1/2 years, compared to a gel that contained no medicine.
To be licensed in the U.S., a gel or cream to prevent HIV infection may need to be at least 80 percent effective, Dr. Fauci said. That might be achieved by adding more tenofovir or getting women to use it more consistently. In the study, women used the gel only 60 percent of the time; those who used it more often had higher rates of protection.
The gel also cut in half the chances of getting HSV-2, the herpes virus that causes genital warts.
Even partial protection is a huge victory that could be a boon not just in poor countries, but for couples anywhere when one partner has HIV and the other does not, said Dr. Salim Abdool Karim, the South African researcher who led the study.
Dr. Karim will present results of the study Tuesday at the International AIDS Conference in Vienna, Austria. The research was published online Monday by the journal Science.
“We now have a product that potentially can alter the epidemic trends … and save millions of lives,” said Dr. Quarraisha Abdool Karim, the lead researcher’s wife and associate director of the South African program that led the testing.
Mitchell Warren, head of the AIDS Vaccine Advocacy Coalition, a nonprofit group that works on HIV-prevention tools, said the study shows a preventive gel is possible.
“We can now say with great certainty that the concept has been proved. And that in itself is a day for celebration,” he said.
The gel is in limited supply. It’s not a commercial product, and was made for this and another ongoing study from drug donated by California-based Gilead Sciences Inc., which sells tenofovir in pill form as Viread. If further study proves the gel effective, a full-scale production system would need to be geared up.
The study tested the gel in 889 heterosexual women in and near Durban, South Africa. Researchers had no information on the women’s partners, but the women were heterosexual and, in general, not in a high-risk group, such as prostitutes.
Half the women were given the microbicide and the others, a dummy gel. Women were told to use it 12 hours before sex and as soon as possible within 12 hours afterward. At the study’s end, there were 38 HIV infections among the microbicide group versus 60 in the others.
The gel seemed safe - only mild diarrhea was slightly more common among those using it. Surveys showed that the vast majority of women found it easy to use and said their partners didn’t mind it. And 99 percent of the women said they would use the gel if they knew for sure that it prevented HIV.
This shows that new studies testing the gel’s effectiveness without a placebo group should immediately be launched, Dr. Salim Abdool Karim said. The only other study testing the gel now compares it with a placebo and will take a few more years to complete.
Please read our comment policy before commenting.