Republican senators shut down calls Friday to hear witnesses against President Trump, matching Democrats’ “half-baked, slapdash” impeachment in the House with the most abbreviated trial in Senate history.
GOP lawmakers said it wasn’t their job to rescue Democrats from their own partisan bungles, rejecting a steady stream of “bombshell” reports that continued to come even as senators voted 51-49, nearly along party lines, to decline to hear witnesses or to subpoena documents.
Immediately after the vote the Senate went into recess, and senators were working to strike a deal on when a final vote might happen, trying to accommodate Democrats who want to be in Iowa campaigning for president.
The two sides appeared to agree to vote later Friday on a schedule that would have them return to session Monday, with a final vote Wednesday.
That would mean Mr. Trump would deliver his State of the Union address Tuesday still under impeachment.
His eventual acquittal is all but certain, though, now that witnesses have been ruled out.
Democrats said there will always be an asterisk next to that verdict.
“A trial without witnesses is not a trial. You can call it something else, but it’s not a trial,” said Rep. Adam Schiff, the Democrats’ top prosecutor.
Republicans said it was rich for him to demand fairness now, after shutting Mr. Trump out of the process in the House, where his team was denied the chance to call witnesses or to cross-examine Democrats’ witnesses in Mr. Schiff’s committee.
“It was their errors,” said Patrick Philbin, one of the president’s lawyers. “They can’t project that onto this body and say you have to make up for their errors, and if you don’t the fault lies here.”
He called the House process “half-baked.”
That argument swayed several key GOP senators who’d been on the fence, but who said the entire process was tainted by Democrats’ truncated impeachment, which seemed timed more to a self-imposed Christmas deadline than to a complete examination of the facts.
“The House did not even bother to subpoena and resolve privilege claims of key witnesses they now want the Senate to subpoena for them,” Sen. Rob Portman, Ohio Republican, said in a statement. “I believe it sets a dangerous precedent – all but guaranteeing a proliferation of highly partisan, poorly investigated impeachments in the future – if we allow the House of Representatives to force the Senate to compel witness testimony that they never secured for themselves.”
Two Republicans — Sens. Susan Collins and Mitt Romney — did break with Mr. Trump and vote to call witnesses.
“I believe hearing from certain witnesses would give each side the opportunity to more fully and fairly make their case, resolve any ambiguities, and provide additional clarity. Therefore, I will vote in support of the motion to allow witnesses and documents to be subpoenaed,” Ms. Collins said in a statement Thursday.
- Gabriella Muñoz contributed to this article.
• Stephen Dinan can be reached at sdinan@washingtontimes.com.
Please read our comment policy before commenting.